Stars explained: * A production of no real merit with failings in all areas. ** A production showing evidence of not enough time or effort, or even talent, and which never breathes any real life into the piece – or a show lumbered with a terrible script. *** A good enjoyable show which might have some small flaws but has largely achieved what it set out to do.**** An excellent show which shows a great deal of work and stage craft with no noticeable or major flaws.***** A four star show which has found that extra bit of magic which lifts theatre to another plane.
Half stars fall between the ratings

squeal

Wild ecstasy, with Laura Hayward-Smith (Squealer) and David Bennett (Napoleon) on top. Pictures: Richard Smith

Animal Farm

The Loft Theatre

Leamington Spa

*****

Sir Peter Hall’s adaptation of George Orwell’s allegorical Animal Farm was devised for the National Theatre to perform in 1984. It has weathered well. Now it’s over four decades old. There are other versions, some inventive, notably ominous and chilling, but this is the version that has enjoyed the most frequent outings.

It was given some music, consistent if of questionable relevance, by Robert Peaslee (a curious cluster of Vaughan Williams) and lyrics by acclaimed playwright and children’s writer Adrian Mitchell. But what mattered most in this explosive Loft production was the mass teamwork and wild animation. The activity was hectic. The large ensemble, every one precisely and meticulously directed by the Loft’s vividly inventive Mark Crossley.

There was endless dashing around: racing, chasing, pushing, pulling, battering, thrusting, scampering, snuffling, seething, sidling: a welter of animal activity. And the noise! Yattering, chattering, yowling, guttural, frenzied; chanting, clamouring: periodically puzzled, here and there increasingly troubled, sometimes disturbingly threatening, even violent. A huge huddle of a constantly twisting assembly.

Orwell’s story, a study in brutality and beastliness, dwells on the rejection of humans and taking over of the farm (‘Our enemy is man’) by the animals, led by the pigs – no actual animal or creature heads here, just hunched and twisting and crawling bodies.

Presiding over the pinched, squeezing tight mass filling the stage was the self-appointed leader, Napoleon (a strutting, selfish, self-satisfied David Bennett), increasingly unpleasant and boastful and domineering: red-trousered (the means of denoting the nasty, smug, malicious pigs). It is inevitable that out of this leaderless gathering a dictator will emerge, and in the second half this manipulative Bonaparte (Bennett) by stages proves his brute force. You cannot resist him. Resistance risks oppression. That can risk a beating, or at worst, removal and death.

snowball

Snowball (Henry Clarke) and Napoleon (David Bennett) before the team falls apart

The pigs’ chief spokesman is an utterly appalling character called Squealer. Ghastly, know-it-all, insuppressible, impossible to silence and mouthing sneeriness or venomous instructions. Laura Hayward-Smith captured with tremendous energy – perfectly, in fact - this nasty piece of work: wheedling, bullying cackling, obnoxiously obedient. ‘Squeal’ is the perfect description. This wickedly nasty, jumped-up, intrusive, pushy, jigging, loud-hailing creature, dominating above on Caitlin Mills’ fascinatingly elaborate wooden set, becomes the trumpet for the ugly new regime. She is a liar, manipulator, cheat, amazingly hyperactive, Hayward-Smith creates a kind of Golum, a mini-monster. A very ghastly, horrendous piece of work. Utterly loathsome.

There is much chuntering, mooing and booing, optimistic or thoroughly confused utterances from the massed farmyard. Elaine Freeborn’s Old Major, although a prize boar, sets the ball rolling with an impressively sane set-piece speech, a modest lecture most finely delivered. Two farm hands, acting occasionally as narrators (Colm Forde, Taylor Kopp), struck me as particularly well-moved and admirably well-spoken too. Cart-horse Clover (Rosie McGuire), who exemplifies put-upon, hapless women in Orwell’s narrative, is sensitive and well-meaning here, and touching Seeking to contribute, but largely, undeservedly, overruled.

Crucial, too, in Animal Farm, are the political horrors and right of life and death exercised by the ruling authority. Revolution devours its perpetrators. One of the best, most unforgettable contributions – speeches, virtually soliloquies – comes from Snowball (Henry Clarke), one of the pigs (in symbolic red trousers), initially guilty perhaps, but more of a free-thinker who becomes conscious of the direction things are edging, and dares – like Trotsky, fatally – to question the wisdom of the leadership. The consequence – he is bundled off to his execution.

Also doomed is the loyal old, cart-hauling stallion Boxer. Mark Roberts, with padded paws, builds several animals up into characters, with an innocence and practised naivety that draws one’s sympathy throughout. But the awfulness of Boxer’s disposal is that his fellow animals are duped into thinking he is destined for ‘hospital’. In some ways, nothing more specially exemplifies the cynicism and ruthlessness of – hence dictatorial Soviet – regimes. Orwell wrote this in 1945: the full violence of Stalin’s 1930s bloodbath was widely known.

If one finds any reservation, it is perhaps that the second half was more lucid. The first part consisted largely of the whole cast accumulating onstage. It felt a bit of a clutter, and the result was that the blocking – or at least the amassing – was rather the same. If on wanted an exemplar – of what could be added by a single actor, onstage, it was the delightful solo/duet from Mollie (Sage Woore): not just fabulously sung, but beautifully lit (several enchanting sequences lit by Adrian Matthews). Might we have benefited from more individual touches, more solo set-pieces, and an emptier stage? Perhaps.

The animals will be down on the farm to 31-01-26

Roderic Dunnett

01-26

The Loft Theatre Company

Home Reviews A-Z Reviews by affiliate